Geico Rating: / 10 (Terrible)
Disclosure: We receive advertising revenue from some partners. Learn more.
High customer satisfaction, a pleasant quote experience and better than average prices.

Geico is well known for its gecko and cavemen “spokespeople” and its entertaining commercials, but the company has a rich history. Originally founded in 1936 as an insurance company for government employees and military personnel, Geico actually stands for Government Employees Insurance Company. Since 1936 it has grown into a company that serves over 9 million auto policyholders from all walks of life. Geico’s financial strength has been rated as excellent by several independent companies. We test drove their website and quote process to evaluate the complete customer experience.

Get a Free Car Insurance Quote >>


To gauge the pricing of the reviewed auto insurance companies, we created 3 different profiles: a 29-year-old, a 37-year-old and a 65-year-old. All 3 profiles were of single men who drove a 2005 Audi Quatro. We then acquired quotes for 2 different cities: San Francisco, CA (urban) and Springfield, IL (residential). Geico performed very respectably, providing better than average pricing when compared to the other auto insurance companies.

Get a Free Car Insurance Quote >>

Shopping Experience

The Geico website is oriented towards customers and features a user-friendly quote machine. During the quote process the participant is asked standard information such as name, address, auto information, employment and driving history. When information is entered Geico searches its databases to match your entries with money saving information. For example, we chose to receive a quote on a 2005 Audi A4. After entering our auto information we were informed our car has an anti-theft device and asked if it also had a “vehicle recovery system” (ie, “LoJack”). The site then advised us that the anti-theft device could save us money on our quote. This happened several times throughout the quoting process. On the last page of the quote we were asked several additional questions (“Do you belong to an Alumni Association”, etc) to help us get the lowest rate on our quote.

We found the complete data entry process to be easy and straightforward. If you have any questions each section has a link to more information. You can also request that an agent call you with the click of a button. When we used this service we were connected with an agent in under 10 seconds.

At the end of the quote process an estimated quote is displayed on screen and you are emailed the quote information. You are able to customize your quote by adding or removing features from the insurance plan such as your Bodily Injury Liability coverage and the Collision Deductible amount. Once again, if you have questions about each feature you only need to click the “?” link to get more information. You can also have an agent call you at any time.

Get a Free Car Insurance Quote >>

Bottom Line

The entire Geico quote process was clear-cut and quick. Customers agree with us, giving Geico top scores for their buying experience. We also found Geico’s quotes to be in line with other auto insurance companies. Customer claim satisfaction, based a JD Power survey, is on the average side. However, customers expressed a high satisfaction level with the overall Geico auto insurance offering. We did too, finding Geico to be our top choice for auto insurance.

Geico offers auto insurance in the following states:

All states except Massachusetts

Request a Free Car Insurance Quote | Compare to Other Auto Insurance


Call (866) 945-4201 to Get Your Free Quote Over the Phone!

Leave a Reply

2506 Customer Comments & Reviews